Thinking before you speak
Feb. 1st, 2010 12:01 pmI don't know how many of you have been following the Amazon vs MacMillan nonsense over the weekend... probably the best link round ups I've seen were on Making light: before and after. ( a brief outline of Amazon vs how the publishing industry works )
Whatever side of this you're on, pricing-wise, DRM-wise, whatever, the upsetting part is that in the middle of ordinary negotiations, Amazon up and said "Oh, we can't deal with this!" and pulled from sale every single title published by MacMillan. This is at least the third or fourth time they've used a similar tactic, generally over a weekend so that the customers start screaming about it before anyone can officially do anything. And ultimately, it's the authors who have been published by the "big evil publishing company" and the readers who want to buy their books who suffer from nonsense like this. I... have been reading mostly people's articles, and avoiding the commentary, but what I'm seeing is a whole lot of people explaining how the publishing industry works in response to angry reactions against authors whose works they can't obtain. Which is downright ridiculous.
I had a conversation with a one-time friend a few months ago, which went somewhat thus:
him: How's it going? What's new with you?
me: Well, I'm volunteering at the Aquarium...
him: Oh? And what's that like?
me: [two sentence description]
him: So, does that take up all your time?
me: No, it's once a week.
him: Oh, so what else are you doing?
me: Well, I'm writing a novel. [It was November. I hold it to be self-evident that anyone who has known me for a few years and pays any attention knows that I'll be writing a novel in November.]
him: Oh, and have you got a publisher lined up for that?
And then he smirked at me and walked off before I could decide whether I wanted to punch him for belittling my choice of lifestyle (we've had conversations before that make it clear he thinks all adults should make enough money to support themselves, which admittedly I haven't since 2003) or for disparaging me without having the faintest idea how the publishing industry works. 'Cause there ain't no publisher in the world who's going to pay an unknown writer for an unfinished first novel.
Oh, and a commentary on Amazon's public statement upon backing down, as through all this they've been trying to paint themselves as consumer-advocates. I found it amusing, at any rate.
Whatever side of this you're on, pricing-wise, DRM-wise, whatever, the upsetting part is that in the middle of ordinary negotiations, Amazon up and said "Oh, we can't deal with this!" and pulled from sale every single title published by MacMillan. This is at least the third or fourth time they've used a similar tactic, generally over a weekend so that the customers start screaming about it before anyone can officially do anything. And ultimately, it's the authors who have been published by the "big evil publishing company" and the readers who want to buy their books who suffer from nonsense like this. I... have been reading mostly people's articles, and avoiding the commentary, but what I'm seeing is a whole lot of people explaining how the publishing industry works in response to angry reactions against authors whose works they can't obtain. Which is downright ridiculous.
I had a conversation with a one-time friend a few months ago, which went somewhat thus:
him: How's it going? What's new with you?
me: Well, I'm volunteering at the Aquarium...
him: Oh? And what's that like?
me: [two sentence description]
him: So, does that take up all your time?
me: No, it's once a week.
him: Oh, so what else are you doing?
me: Well, I'm writing a novel. [It was November. I hold it to be self-evident that anyone who has known me for a few years and pays any attention knows that I'll be writing a novel in November.]
him: Oh, and have you got a publisher lined up for that?
And then he smirked at me and walked off before I could decide whether I wanted to punch him for belittling my choice of lifestyle (we've had conversations before that make it clear he thinks all adults should make enough money to support themselves, which admittedly I haven't since 2003) or for disparaging me without having the faintest idea how the publishing industry works. 'Cause there ain't no publisher in the world who's going to pay an unknown writer for an unfinished first novel.
Oh, and a commentary on Amazon's public statement upon backing down, as through all this they've been trying to paint themselves as consumer-advocates. I found it amusing, at any rate.